Status on m1/m2 update?
Comments
-
I speak about price of subscription just for iPad/android. Users would hardly be happy to pay prices for Mac/PC... Prices for tablets are set roughly tenth of prices for PC/Mac. I am not sur if developers would be eager to subscribe multi K$ bundle for dollar, two a month.
0 -
Subscription service cost is not tiered by the device a user may choose to utilize within the service. There can be tiers for users of different budget levels, but the cost basis is level of content/services.
As an example, video streaming services charge the same whether you access their content with a desktop or a smart phone.
3 -
In about 15 years i have been here i can count on my fingers the number of time the developper team chimed in to say something.So we are left in the dark on what's coming,it's been that way forever.
I agree this would help appease people a bit more,at least have an idea on the plan.It almost feels like they are handcuffed and cannot say a word or they don't read any of the posts in here,not sure.Moderators sometimes talk but they can't say much either.
It creates a wall between the community and the team for sure.
0 -
And it's perhaps the most pivotal period in NI's history... the acquisition into Soundwide has blurred the whole vision of where things may head. I had more confidence when it was just iZotope and NI. A recent exodus of iZotope brainy people has me thinking it's all gonna be just a race to the bottom with Plugin Alliance.
A leader needs to articulate a fairly detailed vision for Soundwide and all its elements pronto.
0 -
That's the point, if no one did that, we'd blame Apple for releasing hardware so bad that developers don't want to work with it. But in reality nearly everyone has an Apple Silicon version now. Sure, I can't blame Vital for not having one because it's free. But everybody else seems to have it. NI seems to be my only problem now.
1 -
Please go and re-read the thread!
For reasons already explained 'in reality nearly everyone' has a product that is much easier to port to Apple Silicon than Reaktor, so Reaktor will take longer to port. If you don't like that take it up with Apple, don't blame NI because they have unique and amazing products. Instead celebrate them, and hassle Apple for making NIs life difficult, and for creating a situation that slows down development in other areas that would benefit all users, not just Apple users!
0 -
Yes, NI has unique and amazing products, that’s why we are all using them.
But NI also has huge technological debt and ancient codebase and frameworks. So who should we blame for years of lack of HiDPI and VST3 for PC, also Apple?
The sad truth is that NI can’t deal with ANY technological change on ANY platform in a timely fashion.
I get that you are anti-Apple, many PC users are. But a bit of objectivity wouldn’t really hurt…
5 -
I guess VST3 and AS native is already ready. Maybe for months. Just NI has decided to release it in Komplete 14 and not sooner.
My bet is that delay does not have technological roots, but economical. AS transition is costly. Developers must reduce costs (VST, AS and K14 in single release).... And maybe somehow motivate users to buy K14 ASAP, e.g. for full upgrade price. My guess is there will be major releases of some products and the older versions will not get AS and maybe even VST3....
Reaktor might be different story. It may take longer....
We will see, hopefully, more in 5-10 weeks....
2 -
<rant>
It seems to me a lot of people reading this thread are only seeing the bits that most disagree or agree with them. AFAI am concerned, Maciej Repetowski is on the nail, and I (don't use Traktor and am just a dabbling hobbyist) can see a time where the portfolio splits into chunks — kept up to date as it can be at low cost and sells, then the rest.
To a large extent it's already Kontakt and the various connected items (Play Series, Studio Guitarist...) and Maschine Expansions which are the bread and butter, very widely used (Kontakt) and able to allow outside sources to deliver content to sell through. I can see a time when Komplete bundles go the way of the dodo as they get ever more bloated with dead wood and great ideas never taken forward as only new stuff sells.
As to Soundwide I wait to be impressed. The inclusions of Plugin Alliance at a point where it seems they've produced lots of great plugins, but are now mining variations of a theme and approaching a Waves level of daily sails as the ownership changes seems to also remove the drive to fix technical debt.
It's odd watching the NI plugins appear on the PA store, to me the price points look risible for the age of some of the items and what's needed is a visible strategy.
In the end it's a market, and purity of position on technology is a luxury compared to actual reality. People will vote with their wallets, rowing about 'it's all X's fault' when we don't see behind the scenes is what will out.
</endrant>
2 -
But NI also has huge technological debt and ancient codebase and frameworks. So who should we blame for years of lack of HiDPI and VST3 for PC, also Apple?
NI has huge technical debt because NI has some very old products with very old codebases. It comes with the territory. That means they have some old products that can only be profitable with small maintenance teams, but at the same time changes take more work and cost more resources... the result is updates are infrequent, and it takes much longer to react to things like AS. It's just the nature of a 'mature' product like Reaktor.
I guess over the years, they could have spent more money on Reaktor to keep the codebase in better order, but then that would have been more expensive and might have resulted in Reaktor being cancelled many years ago due to unprofitability.
Sadly, transitioning to a completely new platform forced upon the industry by Apple probably means that stuff like HiDPI and VST3 will take even longer... unless they decided to incorporate those and other changes at the same time in the context of a large re-write... I seriously doubt it, but fingers crossed!
I get that you are anti-Apple, many PC users are. But a bit of objectivity wouldn’t really hurt…
If what I've said here makes me anti Apple, then what you've said must make you anti Native Instruments, at least I'm on the right forum ;)
0 -
People were asking about HiDPI and VST3 for PCs (and Macs) for at least several years now. Apple’s new processors are only since 2020. What was NI’s excuse before?
NI have had problems with its codebase also in regards of PC platform for many years now. Which you have conveniently omitted from your posts. In your posts it’s all “because of Apple”.
My point is that blaming EVERYTHING about NI on Apple is not even remotely true. That’s why I’ve asked for objectivism…
I repeat: NI has been slow to update their products on both PC and Mac platform for many years now, both from the technical point of view (HiDPI and VST3) and from “feature requests” point of view.
If stating this makes me anti-NI, then so be it.
1 -
People were asking about HiDPI and VST3 for PCs (and Macs) for at least several years now. Apple’s new processors are only since 2020. What was NI’s excuse before?
I don't think NI have made any excuses. Just their usual response - they want to do it, and hopefully will do at some point in the future, but no promises.
NI have had problems with its codebase also in regards of PC platform for many years now. Which you have conveniently omitted from your posts. In your posts it’s all “because of Apple”.
NI have problems with a very old codebase on a very old application. I haven't 'omitted' this. It doesn't change the facts of this debate. You are just trying to steer the discussion away from the relevant facts towards a different argument that nobody disagrees with.
You seem to be implying that I am blaming all problems with NI and Reaktor on Apple, which is patently ridiculous. please stick to the discussion we are actually having :)
Point is that Apple have introduced a new hardware platform, and NI for various legitimate reasons are taking longer to port Reaktor than some of their competitors have taken to port their quite different applications.
I don't really blame anyone for this. I don't think that's a sensible way to look at it. I've already stated that I think a move to ARM is probably a good thing, and that Apple are one of the few companies big enough to make it stick.
The problem here is that there are folk who do clearly need someone to blame, they believe they are entitled to the thing they want, right now, and if that's not happening, someone needs to be blamed, and they have decided that NI are guilty in some way. I'm saying to them that _they_ should go blame Apple.
If this makes me an Apple hater - so be it ;)
0 -
There is a logical fallacy in saying that the blame for lack of M1 native code in timely fashion lays with Apple, because they introduced new type of CPU, thus making life difficult for developers.
By that (flawed) logic, for lack of NI VST3 compatibility (10 years after Steinberg declared depreciation of VST2) we should blame Steinberg (and not NI) and for lack of HiDPI in nearly all NI software, we should blame monitor manufacturers :)
Microsoft will do the same thing like Apple eventually , they are testing waters with ARM and eventually they will force universal binary Win code on developers, it’s just a matter of time when they will become fed up with lack of native ARM Windows apps.
Nvidia wanted so badly to purchase ARM, easy to guess why. But here we have little x86 “don’t change it if it works” club ;)
According to many people here, anytime a technological change of any kind comes, other companies are to be blamed and not NI for lack of timely compatibility. Sorry, but no.
1 -
There is a logical fallacy in saying that the blame for lack of M1 native code in timely fashion lays with Apple, because they introduced new type of CPU, thus making life difficult for developers.
There's yet another straw man
There should be no 'blame' here. It's the Apple users that are demanding to blame someone (If they must, then they they should blame Apple). I'm sure, given the circumstances, that the AS native port of Reaktor will arrive in a timely fashion. They will get it out as soon as possible. Everything else is on hold Reaktor wise, AS is the number one priority. It will be as timely possible.
The facts:
*Apple have introduced a new hardware Platform
*NI have an old product with a large and ancient code base. It is also particularly difficult to port, due to being compiler based
*NI are throwing all their Reaktor resources at getting it done ASAP
*it will be ready as soon as possible
*this is not good enough for some Apple users
Apple users are 'calling out' NI, being negative on the NI forum, and generally being unwilling to accept that this is an (hopefully short term) Apple problem. It's also an NI problem, but not one of their own making (they had enough of those already).
Apple users need to accept that Apple's decision to change the hardware means that some applications will take longer to be ported. This is an inevitable consequence of a new hardware platform... it's not about 'blame' it's just the way it is. It was a decision by Apple, their roadmap is the 'reason' for the problem, without their decision, there would be no problem. Now it's time for their users to be patient, and thankful that NI and other third parties are choosing to support the new platform.
The problem might (we can't know) have been lessened if NI had a more modern codebase, younger applications, and less interesting technologies, but that's hardly a reason to start blaming them for something that they had no control over.
It doesn't matter how you try and frame this or what narrative you try and spin around it, all of this is a direct consequence of Apple introducing a new hardware platform. If *you* must apportion blame *you* cannot legitimately absolve Apple.
2 -
There is still no getting away from the absolute fact that if Apple hadn't switched to a new hardware platform, there would be no problem. Spin it how you will!
It's probably a good thing long term, but change always brings problems, if you can't be patient and deal with problems, then don't be an early adopter... pretty simple really
0
Categories
- All Categories
- 18 Welcome
- 1.6K Hangout
- 66 NI News
- 858 Tech Talks
- 4.4K Native Access
- 17.5K Komplete
- 2.1K Komplete General
- 4.6K Komplete Kontrol
- 6.1K Kontakt
- 1.6K Reaktor
- 397 Battery 4
- 887 Guitar Rig & FX
- 450 Massive X & Synths
- 1.4K Other Software & Hardware
- 6.1K Maschine
- 7.8K Traktor
- 7.8K Traktor Software & Hardware
- Check out everything you can do
- Create an account
- See member benefits
- Answer questions
- Ask the community
- See product news
- Connect with creators