I don’t know if anyone remembers, but a while ago, I started a 'pointless' discussion just to hear other enthusiasts’ opinions. Today, for the same reason, I’m opening another equally 'pointless' discussion haha.
This time, the question is: What do hardware devices actually do better than a digital platform? 'Warmer' is not an acceptable answer. (j.k.)
In my opinion—nothing, except for one thing: Saturation. At least until we get an 'infinite sample rate.' Because I think everything else can be replicated, even the tactile experience, which is often considered a hardware advantage. A good-quality MIDI controller can do the job—and might even provide a better experience.
I’d love to hear your opinions, especially if they contradict mine!