Kontakt: Disable 'save changes to instrument'

creativedialogue
creativedialogue Member Posts: 5 Member
edited October 22 in Kontakt

Every time I have asked this, over many years, the response is, 'not currently available'. That implies it might be, if I bide my time and keep buying Native Instrument products. But it is never addressed, no workaround, no implementation of an alternative, no simple script. Check online, people find this irksome, auditioning and making temporary adjustments should not have to invoke this prompt IMHO. Please implement a change to this time-wasting error on closing an instrument, at least as an option. Thank you!

Tagged:
«1

Comments

  • Kaiwan_NI
    Kaiwan_NI Administrator Posts: 2,860 admin

    Hi @creativedialogue it's a safety feature so that's why there's no option to disable it but I understand your frustrations. I've tagged your post with feature request so we don't miss it.

  • Kubrak
    Kubrak Member Posts: 3,067 Expert

    +1

    It would be beneficial to be able to disable it.

    Think about it as safety feature for those who do not change patches and do not want overwrite stock patches by error.... There is probably many users who do not create their own patches and do not want to get overwritten the stock ones.....

  • kellsmadeit
    kellsmadeit Member Posts: 4 Member

    I agree this is SO annoying. What about the users who don't want to save their random changes to Kontakt libraries?! And then the only solution is to re install the library! This will happen FAR FAR FAR more times then anyone who makes significant enough changes they actually want to alter the library forever but forget to save! This is SO backwards PLEASE fix this, at least make it OPTIONAL!!!!

  • EvilDragon
    EvilDragon Moderator Posts: 1,031 mod
    edited October 2022

    You're in luck, because Kontakt 7 allows you to disable this in case when replacing instruments. Go to Options->Loading->[ ] Ask for confirmation when replacing modified instruments.

    Disable that checkbox. Go merry on your way and hug somebody.


    BTW this sort of behavior is not something that a script would ever be able to resolve, since it's a built-in file loading behavior KSP doesn't have any access to. Just so you know.


    auditioning and making temporary adjustments should not have to invoke this prompt IMHO

    I would disagree with this stance. The program doesn't know if you're just auditioning stuff or doing something else, so it is common sense to ask if you want to save your changes. ANY other program does it, too. Your word processor? Your image editor? Your video editor? It's standard behavior just about everywhere.

  • Mutex
    Mutex Member Posts: 3 Member
    edited November 2022

    Feature request of the following option with a drop down menu to chose from:

    "Ask for confirmation when closing a modified instruments"

    • Yes (default option "Yes")
    • Yes (default option "No")
    • No (Never Ask)

    Alternatively, a changed instrument could have a visual cue instead, like a garbage bin in place of the closing X, so that the user knows beforehand that he's throwing changes away by pressing it.

    Reasoning: Even in a word processor you can open, scroll, close, repeat, through multiple documents without being asked if you want to save changes. That's because scrolling doesn't constitute a change. In Kontakt everything constitutes a change by design, so it becomes annoying real quick when your instruments require you to touch the mod wheel for example. DAWs and Kontakt are all about workflow in the context of music, where not making hard assumptions and letting the musician adjust the software to his workflow has been the norm. Also, musicians are used to go into a store without having a guy standing next to them asking if they now want to buy the instrument every time they pluck a string.

  • Vincent Zaalberg
    Vincent Zaalberg Member Posts: 4 Member
    https://community.native-instruments.com/discussion/comment/35903#Comment_35903

    EvilDragon, your suggestion worked fine one iteration ago. No more prompt when closing down an adjusted patch.

    BUT it seems in the newest Kontakt 7 update this function is broken, correct?

    I can't seem to avoid the prompt message again...

  • EvilDragon
    EvilDragon Moderator Posts: 1,031 mod

    Hmmm no, there have been no changes regarding that option in the latest K7 updates. Still works fine over here.

  • Gee_Flat
    Gee_Flat Member Posts: 906 Guru
    https://community.native-instruments.com/discussion/comment/55004#Comment_55004

    😁"time-wasting error" 😁

    Imagine spending hours tweaking an instrument and losing it becasue this guy is upset over clicking a mouse?

    halfwit!😎

  • EvilDragon
    EvilDragon Moderator Posts: 1,031 mod

    This is why it's an option :)

  • MadBunny
    MadBunny Member Posts: 1 Member
    https://community.native-instruments.com/discussion/comment/55014#Comment_55014

    If a person is doing anything creative on a computer and the time they're allowing between incremental saves is longer than the number of operations they can remember having done, they really aren't in a position to cast aspersions.

  • Gee_Flat
    Gee_Flat Member Posts: 906 Guru
    https://community.native-instruments.com/discussion/comment/55613#Comment_55613

    "The sum of the square roots of any two sides of an isosceles triangle is equal to the square root of the remaining side."

    -- Scarecrow

  • Harmony Core
    Harmony Core Member Posts: 5 Member
    https://community.native-instruments.com/discussion/comment/35903#Comment_35903

    But my word processor and image editor are not asking me to save changes when there are no changes made. In kontakt, it keeps asking to save EVEN IF I haven't touched a single knob, unless kontakt considers pressing the screen keyboard as a "change"

  • Walnut
    Walnut Member Posts: 36 Member

    working fine here, finally glad to see this option

  • Giosan
    Giosan Member Posts: 5 Newcomer

    "Go to Options->Loading->[ ] Ask for confirmation when replacing modified instruments.

    Disable that checkbox."


    Can't make it work in my Kontakt Player 7. It doesn't matter if I used Rosetta 2 or Apple Silicon. Absolut flow-killer. I hope someone could help me with this.

  • Giosan
    Giosan Member Posts: 5 Newcomer

    Here's the worst case. If you want to change Evolve Instrument you should close all 8 racks with 16 mouse-clicks. Even selecting all those 8 racks together for doing only one remove doesn't work. Feels stupid so of course I just remove Kontakt and then open a new one.

This discussion has been closed.
Back To Top

Categories