If I'm going to get one, which should be?
What are their respective strengths and weakness, workflows, etc?
I've watched the videos and listened to the audio samples, but I would like some other perspectives if possible.
Thanks
Both good. Maybe Studio Drummer a little more versatile.
Check also this video for some comparison
They're similar in sound quality and have the same GUI but Studio Drummer gives you over 3,300 drum patterns and 3 different kits, a Pearl Masters Premium Maple kit, a Yamaha Maple Custom Absolute kit and a Sonor SQ2 Drum System. It says the grooves were recorded exclusively for Studio Drummer where as the Abbey Road grooves are more generic. There are 3 options for the kits, Garage, Studio and Stadium so Studio Drummer is more versatile in my opinion and it also includes mapping templates for use with E-DRUMS and other Drum Modules.